What makes a film forgotten? Over time, films either become routinely discussed members of the ever-changing cultural zeitgeist, or fodder for only certain sets of cinephiles. Hell, some are simply forgotten, seemingly never to be spoken of again. That’s why I’ve decided to go ahead and make this list. Considered noteworthy when first debuting (either critically or at the box-office), some of these films garnered considerable acknowledgement from the Academy Of Motion Pictures Arts And Sciences, or were polarizing lightning rods from experimenting auteurs.

Screen Shot 2013-10-15 at 6.26.44 AM

10.) ‘La Vie en Rose’

One of the few foreign language films to win multiple Oscars (at least, one of the few French-language pictures to take home multiple statues), this breathtaking biopic from 2007 is ostensibly the role that introduced the world to its brilliant lead actress Marion Cotillard. A biopic of Edith Piaf, the film is director Olivier Dahan’s most widely-seen picture, at least until his upcoming Nicole Kidman picture Grace Of Monaco. It’s a breathlessly-crafted visual stunner spearheaded by one of the best lead actress turns of the decade. As with many foreign language films, it has since been relatively forgotten by wide audiences, but with star Marion Cotillard taking home the Oscar for this performance and since going on to other massive projects, this is a fitting start for any list of films that made a large splash but have since been seemingly forgotten.

Screen Shot 2013-10-15 at 7.53.22 AM

9.) ‘My Blueberry Nights’

Dahan might not have a name that draws large groups of people into cinemas or forces people to take a look at the picture years after its release, but that’s not the case with Wong Kar-Wai. However, his first foray into English-language filmmaking, fellow 2007-release My Blueberry Nights, is oddly his least talked about work. Often scoffed at as a minor entry into the icon’s oeuvre, this oddly hypnotic faux-melodrama takes his aesthetic to its logical conclusion, becoming a wonderfully scored relationship drama-turned-tone-poem. Boasting a superb lead performance from the breathtaking Norah Jones, the film would be a slight and trite bit of drama in other hands, but it stands as a truly unforgettable picture for those who give themselves over to this misunderstood wonder.

Screen Shot 2013-10-15 at 8.03.04 AM

8.) ‘Roger Dodger’

Going back a bit further in the ‘00s, Dylan Kidd released a little film entitled Roger Dodger, and frankly, there really hasn’t been a film like it since. While Kidd himself has gone on to make more pictures (the upcoming Bryan Cranston-led Get A Job sounds exciting), he has yet to even come close to this film, which is one of the decade’s greatest comedies. With towering turns from a rarely-better Campbell Scott and a young Jesse Eisenberg (as well as names like Isabelle Rossellini, Jennifer Beals and Elizabeth Berkley), this proto-comedy/drama/noir/everything picture gets a beyond-his-years script out of writer/director Kidd. Unfortunately, while it’s chock full of quotable lines and is led by two tour-de-force performances, it’s been left on the back burner in a generation of far more bombastic and less character-driven laugh pictures.

Screen Shot 2013-10-15 at 8.08.33 AM

7.) ‘Keane’

Possibly the least-seen film on this list, this boundary-pushing experiment from director Lodge Kerrigan follows a man on the hunt for his lost daughter. It’s a body blow to the viewer’s senses, and while it may have been forgotten over time, Kerrigan’s film is a brazen and devastatingly emotional drama that, come the final frame, left me speechless. Kerrigan as a director has become relatively forgotten to those outside of the Criterion Collection set (he’s gone the TV route helming episodes of The Killing and Homeland), but with a pair of deeply affecting and still vital cinematic experiments, he’s as interesting a voice as we saw during the aughts.

Screen Shot 2013-10-15 at 8.15.33 AM

6.) ‘Doubt’

It’s been nearly five years since its release in 2008, and this John Patrick Shanley-directed film, despite its killer cast, has seemingly become a footnote in Oscar history. Doubt stars Meryl Streep, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Amy Adams and Viola Davis, and despite their amazing performances it’s rarely given the recognition it deserves as a thought-provoking masterpiece. Besides being a wonderfully muted bit of drama, it’s a rather superb meditation on more than just a woman battling her own faith. An adaptation of a well loved play, the film should be appreciated as the acting class that it truly is, and John Patrick Shanley holds his own as a filmmaker who sadly hasn’t done anything since (his only other directing credit is Joe Versus the Volcano). It’s a damn shame.

Crazy-Heart

5.) ‘Crazy Heart’

Speaking of great performances, very few leading male performances hit in the ‘00s as breathlessly subtle as that of Jeff Bridges in his career-defining turn in Scott Cooper’s Crazy Heart. A wonderfully quiet picture, Bridges is only one-upped, truthfully, by Cooper, a first-time director far beyond his years here. It’s now rarely-talked about, but the film is a delightfully raw picture with an aesthetic that absolutely feels as fresh today as it did in 2009, and I look forward to seeing if Cooper surpasses it with his latest effort, Out Of The Furnace, later this year.

Screen Shot 2013-10-15 at 8.27.15 AM

4.) ‘Shortbus’

Speaking of filmmakers that don’t work nearly often enough, John Cameron Mitchell helmed one of 2006’s greatest pictures and one that has yet to really find any sort of cultural footing. Shortbus is best known for its uncompromising and blunt use of sex, and yet it’s as real and oddly charming a picture as we got during the aughts. Mitchell embeds sex and eroticism directly into his warm and inviting story of a woman on the hunt for a perfect orgasm–the film is not only aesthetically provocative, it also doesn’t just use sex to inspire a visceral reaction. Shortbus captures sex as a real and palpable part of the human experience, and something to be exuberant about. This movie is something to be excited about as well. It’s a masterpiece.

Screen Shot 2013-10-15 at 8.30.38 AM

3.) ‘Gerry’

Easily director Gus van Sant’s most uncompromising effort, this breathtaking kickstarter to his “Death Trilogy” is a tough and truly obtuse picture, but one that nails the viewer as deeply as any film on this list. With career-defining turns from Casey Affleck and Matt Damon, Gerry features two entirely improvised performances and some of the most exciting and brooding direction we’ve ever seen from the experiment-prone van Sant. This haunting tale of two men against nature is a difficult sit for most–which is why many people have either skipped it or forgotten about it–but it’s one of the best films he’s ever made, and unlike anything else we saw at the time.

Screen Shot 2013-10-15 at 8.40.23 AM

2.) ‘Rachel Getting Married’

Speaking of aesthetic experiments, few are more exciting than this picture from director Jonathan Demme. A far cry from Silence Of The Lambs or his documentary work, Rachel Getting Married is an intimate look at a woman coming home for her sister’s wedding, and it’s structurally breathtaking. Nothing is ever telegraphed. Demme and writer Jenny Lumet let the characters and their relationships breathe. While a lot of love was given to Anne Hathaway and co-star Rosemarie DeWitt, Bill Irwin is the real emotional entry point, and his performance is a crowning achievement of character acting. Emotionally devastating and aesthetically thrilling, it absolutely deserves to be listed among the best films of the decade.

Screen Shot 2013-10-15 at 8.35.55 AM

1.) ‘Where The Wild Things Are’

This may be a controversial choice, but Spike Jonze’s adaptation of the legendary Maurice Sendak story is one of the past decade’s most overlooked masterpieces. The most thrilling meditation on childhood since The 400 Blows, Jonze’s film is angry, melancholic and often deeply sad, yet it’s as raw and real a film as you’ll ever witness. Jonze is at the top of his game, and star Max Records one of the most impressive child screen presences of the decade. Toss in a hell of a great supporting cast and you have a film that is deeply resonant yet has seemingly fallen to the wayside since its debut in 2009. It’s time we rediscovered this wild rumpus!

What other great films from 2001-2010 do you think have largely been forgotten? List them in the comment section below.

  • http://www.impassionedcinema.com/ Max Covill

    This list is spot on. I often think of a few of these films, but outside of Where the Wild… and Crazy Heart, I haven’t seen any of them. I’d like to add Happy Go-Lucky to the list as well. A film that was highly praised, but I’ve never seen it.

    I remember wanting to see Doubt really bad. Then it landed with so little momentum I never even gave it a chance.

  • @marko_orlic

    Great list. Always great thinking back on the forgotten ones.

    I’d also add:

    Two Lovers
    The Squid And The Whale
    Half Nelson
    25th Hour
    Revolutionary Road
    Synecdoche, New York
    Sunshine
    About A Boy
    The Proposition
    A Serious Man
    Bad Lieutenant
    Inside Man
    The Savages

  • http://ptsnob.com/ Dan Heaton

    There are some great choices on this list. I definitely agree about My Blueberry Nights. I’d heard that it wasn’t that strong compared to Wong Kar Wai’s other work, but I really enjoyed it. The disappearance of Rodger Dodger is surprising, especially given Eisenberg’s involvement. The top two picks are in the right spots. I just caught up with Rachel Getting Married a few months ago, and it’s a stunning film.

  • anthill panther

    Wicker Park.

  • Jesse Knight

    YES Roger Dodger. What a lightning rod. In America would be on my list.

    • oldfilmsflicker

      so good

  • isavedlatin89

    Glad you guys are digging the list. Any other ones you’d have put on here? I had a few that I was really sad to leave off (read: I left off a good 40). Here are a few:

    Two Lovers, We Own The Night, Revolutionary Road, Michael Clayton, Paranoid Park, Climates, Far From Heaven/I’m Not There, Capote…just a few.

  • Wendell

    Nice list. Rachel Getting Married is amazing. I’d like to add (in no particular order)…

    Maria Full of Grace
    Bamboozled
    25th Hour
    The Wooden Camera
    Sideways
    Mysterious Skin
    Brick
    Inside Man
    Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead
    In Bruges
    Half Nelson
    4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days
    Waltz with Bashir
    Persepolis

    • isavedlatin89

      Bamboozled is one of my favorite films of all time. I’m genuinely pissed it skipped my mind. DAMNIT.

  • http://thevoid99.blogspot.com/ Steven Flores

    With the exception of “Keane”, I have seen everything else though I don’t think “My Blueberry Nights” should be in that list as I think it’s a good but very derivative film. I don’t think Wong Kar-Wai and doing a film in English works for me at all.

    Here’s some films I would put in this list:

    The Go-Getter
    Broken English
    Sylvia
    Girl with a Pearl Earring
    Red Road
    Talk to Me
    Kinky Boots
    Lars and the Real Girl

  • James

    So, seeing “La Vie en Rose” got me thinking that I lent that movie to someone more than a year ago. That person hasn’t returned the film. You should do a movie etiquette piece about when do you ask for a movie back after lending it out. You can expand the feature to a sort of cinematic Ann Landers advice column/etiquette column.

    Dear Movie Mezzanine:

    I went out on a date with someone, and over dinner they shared they were huge fans of the “Transformer” movies. Should I dump this person with atrocious taste in movies immediately? Or should I look past this transgression? I just can’t see myself with a person who actually likes Michael Bay films. Does this make me a movie snob? Or am I reasonable?

    I expect to see the new feature soon on the site.

    Go forth and produce copy.

    That is all.

    • isavedlatin89

      I love this idea, and may or may not actually turn this into a column. This is just brilliant.

  • Juvenile Sinephile

    Rachel Getting Married
    Miami Vice
    Southland Tales
    25th Hour
    Love Songs
    Birth
    24 Hour Party People
    Two Lovers
    Death Proof
    Kung Fu Hustle

  • isavedlatin89

    Guys. HOW DID WE ALL FORGET ABOUT AWAY FROM HER? Is that not the king of all of these? Easily the least talked about BRILLIANT film of the ’00s. I’m ashamed. Well, that and Trash Humpers.

  • Feelm

    Morvern Callar though