• Home
  • Longform
    • Defanging the Unthinkable
      more
      View more

      Defanging the Unthinkable

      9 years ago
    • A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye
      more
      View more

      A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye

      9 years ago
    • The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"
      more
      View more

      The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"

      9 years ago
    • The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"
      more
      View more

      The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"

      9 years ago
  • Interviews
    • A New Way of Telling Love Stories
      more
      View more

      A New Way of Telling Love Stories

      9 years ago
    • Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"
      more
      View more

      Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"

      9 years ago
    • Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast
      more
      View more

      Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast

      9 years ago
    • The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"
      more
      View more

      The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"

      9 years ago
  • Critic-At-Large
    • Now Playing: "From Nowhere"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "From Nowhere"

      9 years ago
    • Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"

      9 years ago
    • Now Playing: "War on Everyone"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "War on Everyone"

      9 years ago
    • Now Playing: "The Salesman"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "The Salesman"

      9 years ago
  • Podcast
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"

      9 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"

      9 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"

      9 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"

      9 years ago
Movie Mezzanine
  • Home
  • Longform
    • Defanging the Unthinkable
      more
      View more

      Defanging the Unthinkable

      9 years ago
    • A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye
      more
      View more

      A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye

      9 years ago
    • The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"
      more
      View more

      The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"

      9 years ago
    • The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"
      more
      View more

      The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"

      9 years ago
  • Interviews
    • A New Way of Telling Love Stories
      more
      View more

      A New Way of Telling Love Stories

      9 years ago
    • Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"
      more
      View more

      Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"

      9 years ago
    • Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast
      more
      View more

      Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast

      9 years ago
    • The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"
      more
      View more

      The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"

      9 years ago
  • Critic-At-Large
    • Now Playing: "From Nowhere"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "From Nowhere"

      9 years ago
    • Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"

      9 years ago
    • Now Playing: "War on Everyone"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "War on Everyone"

      9 years ago
    • Now Playing: "The Salesman"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "The Salesman"

      9 years ago
  • Podcast
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"

      9 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"

      9 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"

      9 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"

      9 years ago
  • Home
  • Longform
    • Defanging the Unthinkable
      more
      View more

      Defanging the Unthinkable

      9 years ago
    • A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye
      more
      View more

      A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye

      9 years ago
    • The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"
      more
      View more

      The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"

      9 years ago
    • The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"
      more
      View more

      The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"

      9 years ago
  • Interviews
    • A New Way of Telling Love Stories
      more
      View more

      A New Way of Telling Love Stories

      9 years ago
    • Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"
      more
      View more

      Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"

      9 years ago
    • Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast
      more
      View more

      Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast

      9 years ago
    • The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"
      more
      View more

      The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"

      9 years ago
  • Critic-At-Large
    • Now Playing: "From Nowhere"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "From Nowhere"

      9 years ago
    • Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"

      9 years ago
    • Now Playing: "War on Everyone"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "War on Everyone"

      9 years ago
    • Now Playing: "The Salesman"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "The Salesman"

      9 years ago
  • Podcast
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"

      9 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"

      9 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"

      9 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"

      9 years ago
<b>Battle of Directors:</b> Stanley Kubrick vs. Terrence Malick
  • Features

Battle of Directors: Stanley Kubrick vs. Terrence Malick

  • by Sam Fragoso
  • February 13, 2013
  • 0
  • 6146

Battle of Directors is a weekly column that pits two filmmakers against one another, sheds light on their respective filmographies, and then asks readers to state which director they prefer. Thoughtful discourse and discussion is encouraged and desired. Enjoy!

Each week I ask readers to take a leap of faith. Some of them do, and some of them end up leaving snippy comments that force me to contemplate the purpose of my existence. Which, coincidentally, is what both filmmakers seem to constantly work at through their own films: existence and what this is all supposed to amount to.

Similar to last week’s pairing (Quentin Tarantino vs. Wes Anderson), there’s a stark dissonance in content and style when it comes to Terrence Malick and Stanley Kubrick. The former auteur is an existential poet with an eye for sweeping and sumptuous landscapes. The latter is a brilliant, creative satirist with the ability to configure some of the most fascinating films ever made. One is more partisan to structured narratives, the other discursive ones.

What Kubrick and Malick have in common is their reclusiveness. The two press-shy and quiet directors take years, sometimes decades in between projects. Yet, while Malick and Kubrick focus on radically different subjects and themes, both make layered and complex films – all of which seem to have something to say. We’re just fortunate enough to listen.

Screen Shot 2013-02-12 at 8.05.40 PM

Five example films from Stanley Kubrick: 

The Shining

2001: A Space Odyssey

Dr Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb

A Clockwork Orange

The Killing

vs.

Screen Shot 2013-02-12 at 11.26.27 PM

Five example films from Terrence Malick: 

Days of Heaven

The Thin Red Line

Badlands

The Tree of Life

The New World

…

So which filmmaker do you prefer?

The choice is yours.

  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Related posts

  • MovieMezzanine
1
Top 5 Movies Based on True Stories

Top 5 Movies Based on True Stories

6 years ago
  • AmirGanjavie
0
László Nemes and Géza Röhrig <br>on “Son of Saul”

László Nemes and Géza Röhrig
on “Son of Saul”

10 years ago
  • AdamNayman
0
“Showgirls” At 20: It’s Better Than You Think

“Showgirls” At 20: It’s Better Than You Think

10 years ago

29 thoughts on “Battle of Directors: Stanley Kubrick vs. Terrence Malick”

  1. Jordan Raup on February 13, 2013 at 9:03 AM said:

    Ah, my two favorite filmmakers. I feel like its impossible to compare, but while I’m more drawn to Malick’s style, Kubrick’s sheer genius gives him the edge.

    • Sam Fragoso on February 13, 2013 at 5:09 PM said:

      These are your two favorite? Well, if so, I apologize Jordan.

  2. Dan Heaton on February 13, 2013 at 9:24 AM said:

    This is nearly impossible. In terms of my favorite films, Days of Heaven is at the top from the filmographies of these two directors. Looking at their entire lists, I do have to give the edge to Kubrick, however. The Shining, Dr. Strangelove, Full Metal Jacket, and 2001 are four classics that put him over the top.

    • Sam Fragoso on February 13, 2013 at 5:08 PM said:

      I’m still having a hard time coming around to Full Metal Jacket.

      As for Days of Heaven, yes, I watched it for the first time last night. Floored me.

      • Dan Heaton on February 13, 2013 at 8:58 PM said:

        I’ve only seen Full Metal Jacket once, and it was just a few years ago. For some reason, my expectations were pretty low, so I was very impressed. Glad to hear that you saw Days of Heaven. That’s such an amazing movie. My favorite from Malick, which is saying a lot.

  3. CineFile on February 13, 2013 at 9:29 AM said:

    You’ve started a street fight between my 18-year-old self and my current self. Do I go with the Clockwork Orange poster on my dorm room wall, or my gape-mouth wide-eyed viewing of Tree of Life?

    I’m going to give it to Kubrick. For The Shining. For Dr. Strangelove. For Eyes Wide Shut. For being the director that really helped me to understand the meaning of auteur.

    Sorry Terrence.

    • Sam Fragoso on February 13, 2013 at 5:07 PM said:

      Love to start fights — particularly intellectually driven ones. I’m inexperienced when it comes to these two filmmakers. Limited. I still need to see Clockwork Orange for example.

  4. Tyler on February 13, 2013 at 9:35 AM said:

    Is The New Wonder your portmanteau of The New World and To the Wonder?

    • Sam Fragoso on February 13, 2013 at 5:05 PM said:

      Haha, apologies for the error … rectified! Anyway, I’m sure you have more to say on this matchup than pointing out a silly error of mine.

  5. James Ewing on February 13, 2013 at 10:29 AM said:

    Malick.

    • Sam Fragoso on February 13, 2013 at 5:04 PM said:

      James. You’ve written essays on Malick. I know you can articulate on this matter. Also what happened to the Days of Heaven analysis?

  6. Christopher Runyon on February 13, 2013 at 12:11 PM said:

    Well fuck, you just picked two of my favorite directors of all time. That being said, Terrence Malick is admittedly my favorite all time filmmaker. However, Kubrick is arguably more important because his The Shining was what got me into movies in the first place and he has a lot of classics.

    I guess I’ll go with Malick since he is, as I said, my favorite filmmaker, but this was a tough one. The Tree of Life and Days of Heaven are more than enough to sway me to the side of Malick, though.

    • Sam Fragoso on February 13, 2013 at 5:04 PM said:

      So long as I can make you squeam, Christopher, I’ve done my job.

      • Christopher Runyon on February 13, 2013 at 5:43 PM said:

        This is all revenge for my staggering anticipation for To The Wonder isn’t it?

    • Nate Schell on June 10, 2019 at 9:38 AM said:

      Shoutout to David Lynch!! One of the only directors who can compare

  7. Joaquin Villalobos on February 13, 2013 at 12:50 PM said:

    As a whole, Kubrick.

    • Sam Fragoso on February 13, 2013 at 5:01 PM said:

      Care to elaborate?

  8. Steven Flores on February 13, 2013 at 1:54 PM said:

    Shit… this is not a battle of the directors. This is a battle of the Gods. Two titans in the world of American Cinema. Two of the great American filmmaking Auteurs ever…

    Fuck man. I guess I have to go with Malick. So far from what I’ve seen. The dude is batting a thousand. He’s made one great film after another. I know there’s been mixed reviews about “To the Wonder” but that’s not going to stop me from seeing it.

    I love Kubrick. I think anything he did from “Lolita” to “Eyes Wide Shut” is a track record that can’t be matched by anyone. Except for Malick maybe. If Kubrick was alive, I think he would find his match.

    • Sam Fragoso on February 13, 2013 at 5:01 PM said:

      It’s interesting to contemplate what Kubrick would be doing now. If anything.

      • Steven Flores on February 13, 2013 at 7:05 PM said:

        Ok, what about Kubrick vs. Malick if it was a pro wrestling match?

  9. James on February 13, 2013 at 7:05 PM said:

    First, I think you left one of Krubrick’s best films — “Paths of Glory” — off the list. But if I have to chose with the five films you have included in your sample, I’d go with Malick. “The Killing” is a very good genre film, but not classic like all five of the Malick films you list. Now, if you took “The Killing” out and replaced it with “Paths,” I’d go with Krubrick by a nose.

    • Sam Fragoso on February 15, 2013 at 7:43 PM said:

      You’re not limited to the five films mentioned. Malick only has five though, so I did what I could to make the matchup more even. I still very much enjoy “The Killing” … it’s not major Kubrick by any standards. But it’s a fun little genre heist film.

  10. TheOneWhoKnocks on February 13, 2013 at 7:14 PM said:

    This is definitely the hardest battle of directors yet, and props for
    making this column because it’s great. This is hard because I love
    Malick, but honestly I can’t just can’t not pick Kubrick. For me he is
    The Auteur. His career has flourished in both critical and commercial
    fame, being the only director who’s almost every film is both a
    touchstone of pop-culture and a challenging enigma at the same time.
    Whenever I question the power of cinema, I can watch a Kubrick film, and
    be relieved. I also think “2001: A Space Odyssey” is the greatest film ever made, so there’s that.

    • Sam Fragoso on February 15, 2013 at 7:41 PM said:

      Appreciate your support man. Glad you enjoy the column.

      It’s very rare for a filmmaker to garner both critical and commercial success. And it’s good that you can find solace in a filmmaker.

  11. Alex Withrow on February 15, 2013 at 9:08 AM said:

    Tough, man, tough. Gotta go Kubrick here.

    • Sam Fragoso on February 15, 2013 at 7:39 PM said:

      You know I try to make this tough Alex.

  12. Seb Moore on February 18, 2013 at 4:46 AM said:

    it’s close, but ive gotta go with Kubrick. his overall influence on various genres and the medium as a whole is unparalleled. the only other living director who looks like he could be a challenger imo is Paul Thomas Anderson. we’ll see how his filmography stands up in 20 years time. i think if we were just considering living directors, Malick vs Haneke is a great matchup. they’re polar opposites in terms of themes and style, but they’re both great in their own right. another great matchup would be Paul Thomas Anderson vs The Coen bros.

  13. Alex Deschênes on July 24, 2014 at 3:15 PM said:

    My choice is definitely Terrence Malick…! Definitely may hurt some people here, I know, but here’s why :

    I ended here by making a search on google on Kubrick and Malick, just to say how I estimate both. Malick is my favorite director of all time, and “2001” maybe my favorite movie ever. Never a movie left such a deep effect on me. (But two movies come close : “The New World” and “The Tree of Life”.

    But, the more I watch their respective filmographies, the more I feel Malick tries to answer to Kubrick, and mostly with The Tree of Life. The problem why I can’t appreciate Kubrick as I would like is because of how he was sometimes excessive. I agree with all Ebert’s reviews of Kubrick’s movies, including his disdain of “A Clockwork Orange”. Kubrick was a genius, but an excessive genius, a tormented one… while Malick is more – I have to say – peaceful. He’s a kind of modern Shakespeare, who can write about evil and film beautiful tragedies (“Badlands”, “Days of Heaven”) without ever contempting in it… which Kubrick doesn’t escape. And Kubrick is more like the excessive Marlowe… we all know how Kubrick could be cruel with his actors. Kubrick was obsessed with the dark side of human, and even if some movies are clearly anti-war, some are really more ambiguous (“A Clockwork Orange”, “Lolita”, “Eyes Wide Shut”), to say that this obsession sometimes turned to fascination and seduction.

    I talked more about Kubrick than Malick, but what can I say, except that is movies are SO rich, so sensitive (although many say the contrary), so deep and incarnated. Malick seems inspired by phenomenology. Although people tend to oppose Malick and Kubrick, I think they ask the same deep questions about human existence, but I would say that Malick has more answers (or attempts to answer) than Kubrick. I think Malick find some meaning where Kubrick sees none and somehow deperate about human and life in general.

    So, finally, I would say that Malick has a better long effect on me than Kubrick, and for that reason, I do not hesitate to choose him.

    My favorite movies of all-time (all directors included) :
    1 – 2001: A Space Odyssey
    2 – The New World
    3 – The Tree of Life

  14. Tal Doron on June 12, 2021 at 12:18 AM said:

    I love Malick’s work. But there is only one Kubrick

About Us

Movie Mezzanine is an online publication dedicated to covering the medium that connects us all, one film at a time. With writers stationed around the globe, we offer a uniquely diverse perspective on cinema, both old and new. To learn more about us, go here.

Spotlight

Putting the Geek to the Plow

Cleantalk Pixel