• Home
  • Longform
    • Defanging the Unthinkable
      more
      View more

      Defanging the Unthinkable

      6 years ago
    • A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye
      more
      View more

      A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye

      6 years ago
    • The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"
      more
      View more

      The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"

      6 years ago
    • The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"
      more
      View more

      The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"

      6 years ago
  • Interviews
    • A New Way of Telling Love Stories
      more
      View more

      A New Way of Telling Love Stories

      6 years ago
    • Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"
      more
      View more

      Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"

      6 years ago
    • Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast
      more
      View more

      Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast

      6 years ago
    • The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"
      more
      View more

      The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"

      6 years ago
  • Critic-At-Large
    • Now Playing: "From Nowhere"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "From Nowhere"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "War on Everyone"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "War on Everyone"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "The Salesman"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "The Salesman"

      6 years ago
  • Podcast
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"

      6 years ago
Movie Mezzanine
  • Home
  • Longform
    • Defanging the Unthinkable
      more
      View more

      Defanging the Unthinkable

      6 years ago
    • A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye
      more
      View more

      A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye

      6 years ago
    • The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"
      more
      View more

      The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"

      6 years ago
    • The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"
      more
      View more

      The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"

      6 years ago
  • Interviews
    • A New Way of Telling Love Stories
      more
      View more

      A New Way of Telling Love Stories

      6 years ago
    • Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"
      more
      View more

      Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"

      6 years ago
    • Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast
      more
      View more

      Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast

      6 years ago
    • The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"
      more
      View more

      The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"

      6 years ago
  • Critic-At-Large
    • Now Playing: "From Nowhere"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "From Nowhere"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "War on Everyone"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "War on Everyone"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "The Salesman"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "The Salesman"

      6 years ago
  • Podcast
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"

      6 years ago
  • Home
  • Longform
    • Defanging the Unthinkable
      more
      View more

      Defanging the Unthinkable

      6 years ago
    • A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye
      more
      View more

      A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye

      6 years ago
    • The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"
      more
      View more

      The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"

      6 years ago
    • The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"
      more
      View more

      The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"

      6 years ago
  • Interviews
    • A New Way of Telling Love Stories
      more
      View more

      A New Way of Telling Love Stories

      6 years ago
    • Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"
      more
      View more

      Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"

      6 years ago
    • Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast
      more
      View more

      Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast

      6 years ago
    • The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"
      more
      View more

      The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"

      6 years ago
  • Critic-At-Large
    • Now Playing: "From Nowhere"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "From Nowhere"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "War on Everyone"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "War on Everyone"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "The Salesman"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "The Salesman"

      6 years ago
  • Podcast
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"

      6 years ago
“Truth” is Better Than “Fiction”: Documentaries That Trump Their Fictional Equivalents
  • Features / List

“Truth” is Better Than “Fiction”: Documentaries That Trump Their Fictional Equivalents

  • by Dan Schindel
  • November 19, 2014
  • 0
  • 4125

Biopics are as beloved by Oscar voters as they are joked about by almost everyone else. And many a thinkpiece has been written about why Hollywood loves biopics, and why so many of them are so very samey. But I come not to mourn the biopic. Nor do I come to bury it. I come to assume the genre (or its artistic credibility, that is) is already buried, and to suggest some alternatives to it.

Why? Because the film industry likes to ignore documentaries, even more than it loves to prop up based-on-a-true-story movies. But cinema—when freed of the need to conform to traditional storytelling structure, or awkwardly explore a famous figure’s life in such a way that is best conducive to an actor’s Oscar-courting—can truly grapple with fascinating, real-life people. Here are just a few examples of documentaries that trumped fictional adaptations of their subjects.

A Brief History of Time > The Theory of Everything

large_a_brief_history_of_time_05_blu-ray_

Here we have an example of how people talking about their histories can prove to be more engaging than recreations of those same events. The Theory of Everything takes place over the exact same timeframe as related in A Brief History of Time, sometimes with overlapping anecdotes (such as main subject Stephen Hawking talking about breezing through college exams). The only big difference is that Theory explores Hawking’s marriage, something that Brief History doesn’t really touch upon. This is likely because at the time of its making, Hawking and his wife had recently separated, but this was not public knowledge. So why is the biopic, which has access to this more emotional material, still lesser than the doc? It’s probably because Theory is so hidebound to cliché, whereas Brief History is a mesmerizing conversation with Hawking and those who know him best.

A bunch of Ali docs > Ali

when_we_were_kings_1997_1024x768_911728-1000high

There are an awful lot of documentaries about Muhammad Ali, enough that a whole list could have been drawn up about them. The most obvious documentary alternative to the Will-Smith-starrer Ali is When We Were Kings. Given that it’s a widely loved Oscar winner, it’s almost unfair to compare anything to When We Were Kings, but the thrilling account of the “Rumble in the Jungle” event gets at why the man garnered such a devoted following.

Meanwhile, The Trials of Muhammad Ali focuses more on the boxer as a political icon, chronicling his legal battle against his five-year prison sentence for refusing to serve in Vietnam. And Facing Ali takes an interesting tack to the man as myth by talking to various boxers who have faced him in the ring. All of these convey Ali’s considerable talent and charisma straight from the man himself. Accept no substitutes (even if it is Will Smith).

The Aileen films > Monster

aileen-wuornos-selling-of-a-serial-killer-s1e1-20090608152251_625x352

British documentarian Nick Broomfield made not one but two films about infamous serial killer Aileen Wuornos. The first, Aileen: The Selling of a Serial Killer, explores how the media sensationalized her story, while the second, Aileen: Life and Death of a Serial Killer, follows Wuornos in the last days before her execution. Pop culture often has trouble balancing its lurid fascination with serial killers with good taste and respectfully depicting true events, and Monster isn’t much different. Broomfield’s films are able to explore how law and order deals with insane individuals, without grisly, exploitative recreations of real murders. Charlize Theron watched The Selling of a Serial Killer multiple times in order to better imitate Wuornos in Monster. I can’t think of a better example of how biopics are often just playing catch-up to docs.

General Idi Amin Dada: A Self Portrait > The Last King of Scotland

Amin-2

Forest Whitaker gives a fine performance in this film, but it’s bogged down by its utterly unnecessary, white, European-viewpoint protagonist. In this doc, Amin himself is the lead, witnessed and interviewed while he was still in power. The brutality of his regime lurks in the margins, though his martial obsessions are front and center. The film offers an eerie, unforgettable profile of a monster, with no need for white “gateway” characters.

Little Dieter Needs to Fly > Rescue Dawn

Little-Dieter-Needs-to-Fly

Rescue Dawn is a very good film. But it can’t match the sheer eccentric genius of the documentary on which it was based, made by the same director—the inimitable Werner Herzog. While Rescue Dawn plays with the conventions of war and prison breakout movies, Little Dieter is about living in the aftermath of trauma, and the sad or even humorous oddities that this creates. And it contains unforgettable footage of Dieter Dengler returning to the place where he was captured and held prisoner and re-enacting those events … Complete with locals recruited to play his captors.

The Times of Harvey Milk > Milk

large_times_of_harvey_milk_blu-ray_6

This is yet another example of a fiction film that drew direct influence from the doc in question, but it runs deeper than cribbing plot points. At certain points, Milk straight-up uses footage and/or recordings that come straight from The Times of Harvey Milk. And yet Times still manages to be a deeper emotional experience than Sean Penn giving things his all. Perhaps that’s because the biopic foregrounds Harvey Milk and takes a Cliff’s Notes approach to his accomplishments, while Times helps us understand why Milk was so important to his community, and makes his loss hurt all the more for it.

Grey Gardens > Grey Gardens

large_grey_gardens_01_blu-ray_

Now we’re getting even more surreal, because HBO’s fictional Grey Gardens incorporates the filming of the documentary Grey Gardens into its plot. But for all the effort that Drew Barrymore and Jessica Lange throw into portraying “Little” Edie and “Big” Edie Beale, there’s nothing, nothing that compares to watching the real women in action. All of the best lines of dialogue in the fiction piece are pretty much cribbed directly from things that the Beales said offhand in the doc. Hearing Little Edie or Big Edie describe events of their lives is far more riveting than seeing them re-enacted in the HBO film. Truth is stranger than fiction, which makes it a lot more fun.

The Paradise Lost Trilogy > Devil’s Knot

Paradise-Lost-3

It’s a stretch to call Devil’s Knot a biopic, because in an utterly baffling move, a film about the infamously wrongly-imprisoned West Memphis Three is not actually about the Three. Rather, it follows Colin Firth being sad about them and trying to prove their innocence. Somehow, this proves less effective than footage of those young men being hung out to dry in a courtroom, or of ignorant townspeople baying for the blood of “Satanists.” Joe Berlinger and Bruce Sinofsky were on top of the West Memphis Three story from the beginning, and they kept coming back to it over the years, ultimately making three documentaries that capture the whole story, rather than the abridged version told in Devil’s Knot. The docs are often messy, but then, it was a messy situation, and they’re still a hundred times more involving than Atom Egoyan’s lackluster dramatization.

Tags
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Related posts

  • MovieMezzanine
0
Top 5 Movies Based on True Stories

Top 5 Movies Based on True Stories

4 years ago
  • AmirGanjavie
0
László Nemes and Géza Röhrig <br>on “Son of Saul”

László Nemes and Géza Röhrig
on “Son of Saul”

7 years ago
  • JustineSmith
7
The 20 Best French Horror Films Ever

The 20 Best French Horror Films Ever

7 years ago

One thought on ““Truth” is Better Than “Fiction”: Documentaries That Trump Their Fictional Equivalents”

  1. Pingback: The Week that Was: 11/17 - 11/23

About Us

Movie Mezzanine is an online publication dedicated to covering the medium that connects us all, one film at a time. With writers stationed around the globe, we offer a uniquely diverse perspective on cinema, both old and new. To learn more about us, go here.

Spotlight

Putting the Geek to the Plow

Cleantalk Pixel