• Home
  • Longform
    • Defanging the Unthinkable
      more
      View more

      Defanging the Unthinkable

      6 years ago
    • A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye
      more
      View more

      A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye

      6 years ago
    • The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"
      more
      View more

      The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"

      6 years ago
    • The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"
      more
      View more

      The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"

      6 years ago
  • Interviews
    • A New Way of Telling Love Stories
      more
      View more

      A New Way of Telling Love Stories

      6 years ago
    • Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"
      more
      View more

      Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"

      6 years ago
    • Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast
      more
      View more

      Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast

      6 years ago
    • The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"
      more
      View more

      The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"

      7 years ago
  • Critic-At-Large
    • Now Playing: "From Nowhere"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "From Nowhere"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "War on Everyone"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "War on Everyone"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "The Salesman"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "The Salesman"

      6 years ago
  • Podcast
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"

      6 years ago
Movie Mezzanine
  • Home
  • Longform
    • Defanging the Unthinkable
      more
      View more

      Defanging the Unthinkable

      6 years ago
    • A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye
      more
      View more

      A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye

      6 years ago
    • The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"
      more
      View more

      The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"

      6 years ago
    • The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"
      more
      View more

      The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"

      6 years ago
  • Interviews
    • A New Way of Telling Love Stories
      more
      View more

      A New Way of Telling Love Stories

      6 years ago
    • Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"
      more
      View more

      Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"

      6 years ago
    • Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast
      more
      View more

      Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast

      6 years ago
    • The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"
      more
      View more

      The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"

      7 years ago
  • Critic-At-Large
    • Now Playing: "From Nowhere"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "From Nowhere"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "War on Everyone"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "War on Everyone"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "The Salesman"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "The Salesman"

      6 years ago
  • Podcast
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"

      6 years ago
  • Home
  • Longform
    • Defanging the Unthinkable
      more
      View more

      Defanging the Unthinkable

      6 years ago
    • A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye
      more
      View more

      A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye

      6 years ago
    • The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"
      more
      View more

      The Ambivalent, Bittersweet "My Life as a Zucchini"

      6 years ago
    • The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"
      more
      View more

      The Complex Morality of "No Country for Old Men"

      6 years ago
  • Interviews
    • A New Way of Telling Love Stories
      more
      View more

      A New Way of Telling Love Stories

      6 years ago
    • Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"
      more
      View more

      Breaking Standards with Julian Rosefeldt of "Manifesto"

      6 years ago
    • Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast
      more
      View more

      Indulging Mightily with Alex Ross Perry and the "Golden Exits" Cast

      6 years ago
    • The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"
      more
      View more

      The Ultimate Meta-Performance: Kate Lyn Sheil on "Kate Plays Christine"

      7 years ago
  • Critic-At-Large
    • Now Playing: "From Nowhere"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "From Nowhere"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "Fifty Shades Darker"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "War on Everyone"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "War on Everyone"

      6 years ago
    • Now Playing: "The Salesman"
      more
      View more

      Now Playing: "The Salesman"

      6 years ago
  • Podcast
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 287: "Kundun"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 286: "Pinocchio"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 285: "That Darn Cat"

      6 years ago
    • Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"
      more
      View more

      Mousterpiece Cinema, Episode 284: "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement"

      6 years ago
  • Longform

On “Trumbo” And Hollywood’s Love Affair With Itself

  • by Noah Gittell
  • January 13, 2016
  • 1
  • 3185
On “Trumbo” And Hollywood’s Love Affair With Itself

If you’re watching the live broadcast of the Oscar nominations tomorrow morning, you are likely doing so out of hope. Or perhaps out of love. What else would inspire an otherwise-logical human to get up early–really early, at 5:30am PST, if you’re on the West Coast–to simply watch the nominations, which will be available online within seconds, being read aloud? We do so because we care about these movies, and, at that particular moment, there is nothing we want more than to hear the name of our favorite film announced as a contender for the Academy’s Best Picture of the year.

Not me, though. On Thursday, I won’t be looking out for my favorite film of the year. I’ll be looking out for Trumbo–not because I loved it (or hated it, for that matter), but out of pure fascination. The biopic of blacklisted screenwriter Dalton Trumbo provides perhaps the greatest test yet of Hollywood’s recent infatuation with itself. In 2012, Best Picture went to The Artist, a slight, comedic pastiche about a silent film star who falls on tough times as the film industry shifts to talkies (with the arguable runner-up at that year’s Oscars being the cinema-stumping Hugo). In 2013, it was Argo, an efficiently tense pop thriller about how Hollywood producers helped the government save hostages from Iran. The Academy wisely awarded 12 Years a Slave in 2014, although it only narrowly fended off a late charge from Gravity, which is not about the movie industry but the high box-office grosses made Hollywood a pretty penny. And in 2015, the Academy went back to their artist-aggrandizing navel-gazing, awarding Best Picture to Birdman.

That’s three insular tales of Hollywood or an actor-writer-director’s struggle in four years. And before you point out that this has always been an industry in love with itself, consider these facts. Before The Artist, no film about the movie business had ever won Best Picture. Never. In fact, only five other winners could conceivably even be considered to be about show business: Chicago (2002), Shakespeare in Love (1999), All About Eve (1950), The Great Ziegfield (1939), and The Broadway Melody (1929). There may have been good reason that the Academy avoided celebrating showbiz tales in the past. Even though the primary purpose of the Oscars is to promote the industry, people want stories they can relate to, and most of them aren’t in the movie business.

So does Trumbo have a chance? There are some significant arguments against it. While The Artist, Argo, and Birdman each sported some substantial artistic and commercial victories, Trumbo has been loved by almost no one. It earned only $7 million at the box office, which is not terrible given how few screens it was released on but hardly indicates popular support. It received reviews ranging from tepid appreciation to downright loathing, receiving a middling composite score of 60 on Metacritic. And even those who do like it seem to only appreciate the performances. Cranston and Mirren received good notices for their admittedly competent performances, but no one—and I mean, no one—is suggesting Jay Roach should be in the Best Director conversation for his point-and-shoot visual style.

trumbo

And yet the precursors indicate it will have considerable support among voting members. Bryan Cranston and Helen Mirren were both nominated for Golden Globes, even if they lost this past Sunday. The entire cast was nominated for Best Ensemble at the SAG Awards (Cranston and Mirren were also nominated individually), and, of course, actors make up the biggest voting bloc of the Academy. If this were the old days, when the Academy nominated only five films for Best Picture, we wouldn’t be having this conversation. But if The Blind Side and Philomena can find its way in, why not Trumbo?

If Trumbo does sneak into the Best Picture conversation, it will demonstrate just how narrow the Academy’s tastes have gotten. What accounts for this change? It’s always tempting to look at the Academy as a monolith, but in reality, it is made up of over 6,000 individuals with their own tastes and agendas—all of whom are subject to the same social forces and personal biases as the rest of us. So here’s a theory: maybe Hollywood’s increasing self-interest is a reflection of the same narrowing impulse that has driven American culture and politics these last few years. In his influential 2008 book The Big Sort, Bill Bishop argues that over the past four decades, Americans have been sorting themselves into communities where people increasingly look and behave just like them. More recently, that process has evolved into our online lives, which are quickly superseding our actual lives. We carefully curate our Facebook and Twitter feeds to include those people whom we agree with, or at least think similarly to, and exclude those we don’t. We block, we mute, and we unfriend, and not always because of abusive behavior. More often, we do it because someone simply represents a viewpoint that is foreign or distasteful. Our thinking has become more myopic, our politics more polarized than at any time since the Civil War, and our society as dysfunctional and counter-productive as ever.

So why wouldn’t the Academy fall victim to the same social dynamics? Imagine a voter whose day is filled with conversations, posts, and comments mostly about filmmaking. Surely, they would gravitate to stories about those same themes, and when it came time to vote their conscience, they would inevitably feel drawn to movies about their own community because, to many of them, that’s all the world is.

And really, that’s the only explanation for why Trumbo could earn a spot among the year’s ten best films that makes sense, even to critics like me who love political movies. It’s a film that speaks directly to Hollywood insiders, and if offers them the most generous self-reflection. While Trumbo fashions itself as an exposé of the traumas of the McCarthy era, it presents its history in a purely congratulatory, black-and-white fashion and fails to connect its subject to any contemporary events or issues, which is what we expect from a great historical film. Ultimately, it keeps the industry’s ugly past squarely in the past. The film even closes on a famous speech of Trumbo’s that exonerates those who named names before the House Un-American Activities Committee, smoothing over the rough edges of Hollywood’s ugly history and presenting it as a problem solved. It’s easy to understand why that would appeal to Academy members, but if it wins a chance to earn their highest honor, it speaks to a pervasive social problem that runs far deeper.

—

Original illustration by Krishna Shenoi.

Noah Gittell
Noah Gittell has contributed to The Atlantic, Washington City Paper, Esquire, LA Review of Books, IndieWIRE, and others. He blogs at Reel Change. The first movie that rocked his world was Boogie Nights.
Tags
  • 0
  • 1
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
Spotlight
  • The 20 Best French Horror Films Ever

  • Now Playing: "Office Christmas Party"

  • Top 10 Films About Loneliness And Isolation

Mezzanine on Facebook
Mezzanine on Twitter
  • Movie Mezzanine: RT @SamFragoso: Needing some light, I went to see THE FLORIDA PROJECT (again). It's a glorious achievement from Sean Baker. Something worth…
    over a year ago
  • Movie Mezzanine: RT @SamFragoso: Hit & miss #TIFF17 but much love to @Lilfilm and his team. THE FLORIDA PROJECT is a gem. These images keep replaying in my…
    over a year ago
  • Movie Mezzanine: RT @TalkEasyPod: King @TheNormanLear goes over 95 years of life with us this week. A true national treasure. https://t.co/a4AfIk6vBo
    over a year ago
  • Movie Mezzanine: RT @elazic: BLOW-UP screens August 22 6:30pm at Somerset House for @Film4 Summer Screen! My piece on the film's eternal relevance for @Movi…
    over a year ago
  • Movie Mezzanine: RT @sheilakathleen: For Richard Linklater's bday: my essay on Before Sunrise for @MovieMezzanine : https://t.co/WBdMx7v4Sb https://t.co/xS4…
    over a year ago
Follow us @MovieMezzanine
Sponsored by The Critical Press
Newsletter

Related posts

  • NathanaelHood
80
Defanging the Unthinkable

Defanging the Unthinkable

6 years ago
  • AndyHoglund
81
A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye

A Fitting, Impressive Goodbye

6 years ago
  • MichaelSicinski
91
The Ambivalent, Bittersweet “My Life as a Zucchini”

The Ambivalent, Bittersweet “My Life as a Zucchini”

6 years ago

Comments are closed.

About Us

Movie Mezzanine is an online publication dedicated to covering the medium that connects us all, one film at a time. With writers stationed around the globe, we offer a uniquely diverse perspective on cinema, both old and new. To learn more about us, go here.

Spotlight

Putting the Geek to the Plow

Cleantalk Pixel